Fernanda Pizzammiglio

Fernanda Pizzammiglio Florida Realtor 🇺🇸 🇧🇷

$3,100,000.00
457 E NEW ENGLAND AVENUE, WINTER PARK, FL - 32789
5 beds
4.5 baths
3,896 sqft
$3,100,000.00
457 E NEW ENGLAND AVENUE, WINTER PARK, FL - 32789
Fernanda Pizzammiglio
$3,100,000.00
5 beds
4.5 baths
3,896 sqft
457 E NEW ENGLAND AVENUE, WINTER PARK, FL - 32789
For Sale
Photo 1
  • Built in 1920
  • $795.69/sqft
  • Lot size: 18,001 sqft
  • 132 days on market

Nestled in the heart of downtown Winter Park, this beautifully maintained 1920s traditional residence captures the essence of Old Florida charm while offering the comfort of modern amenities. From the moment you arrive, the wraparound porch and circular drive create a welcoming first impression, setting the tone for the timeless character found throughout. Step inside to a gracious foyer accented by a cozy fireplace, leading into the spacious formal living room with its own gas fireplace and the elegant formal dining room. Gorgeous heart-of-pine floors run throughout the first floor, adding warmth and authenticity. The kitchen has been thoughtfully updated with top-of-the-line Thermador and Sub-Zero appliances, including a 72-bottle Sub-Zero wine tower and refrigerated drawers, making it as functional as it is beautiful. Open to the family room, complete with rich woodwork and a third gas fireplace, this space is ideal for gathering and entertaining. The primary suite is conveniently located on the first floor and features an updated ensuite bath. Upstairs, three additional bedrooms and two renovated baths provide comfortable accommodations for family and guests. A charming “sleeping room,” now used as a light-filled office, overlooks picturesque New England Avenue. Adding to the property’s appeal is a detached two-story guest house offering a full bedroom, full bath, sitting area, and kitchen—perfect for extended stays or as a private retreat. Outdoor living is equally inviting, with a back porch for grilling, a separate patio for lounging and mature landscaping that enhances the home’s curb appeal. Architectural details available for adding an oversize two-car garage, if desired. Perfectly positioned on the same block as The Alfond Inn and just two short blocks from the renowned Park Avenue district, this home offers not just refined living, but a downtown walkable lifestyle that is truly unmatched. Park Avenue is the cultural heart of Winter Park—a tree-lined promenade alive with award-winning restaurants, boutique shopping, art galleries and historic landmarks. Residents enjoy a vibrant calendar of events, from the Winter Park Farmers’ Market and seasonal art festivals to beloved holiday parades and outdoor movies under the stars. Here, every day is an invitation to experience the best of Central Florida living—whether it’s sipping coffee at a charming café, strolling to or after dinner surrounded by beautiful ambience, or embracing the timeless traditions that make Winter Park so treasured.

  • Directions: From Fairbanks Ave. and S Park Ave., travel north on S Park Ave. Turn right on E New England Ave. Home is on the left at the corner of New England Ave. and Chase Ave.
  • County: Orange
  • Geo subdivision: WINTER PARK

Nearby Schools

Audubon Park K8

Audubon Park K-8

Winter Park High

Features

Financial

Let's get in touch!

Fernanda Pizzammiglio

Fernanda Pizzammiglio

Florida Realtor 🇺🇸 🇧🇷

See also

For Sale
1821 ENGLEWOOD ROAD, WINTER PARK, FL - 32789
$3,135,000.00
5 bds
5.5 ba
3,863 sqft
1821 ENGLEWOOD ROAD, WINTER PARK, FL - 32789
For Sale
1761 LEGION DRIVE, WINTER PARK, FL - 32789
$3,295,000.00
5 bds
5.5 ba
4,955 sqft
1761 LEGION DRIVE, WINTER PARK, FL - 32789
For Sale
541 W CANTON AVENUE, WINTER PARK, FL - 32789
$2,935,000.00
4 bds
3.5 ba
3,553 sqft
541 W CANTON AVENUE, WINTER PARK, FL - 32789
Stellar MLS
  • Source: Stellar MLS
  • MLS #: O6345511
Listing updated: February 23, 2026 at 5:57PM
Listing provided by: Mick Night, PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTL. REALTY
Last checked 4 days ago
IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website.